Monday, January 23, 2012

Do You Make These 5 Common Mistakes During Group Time?

Are you struggling to keep the children engaged, especially during whole group activities? You might be making some of the following mistakes: 
  • Don’t talk over the children. Be sure you use your quiet signal to get all the children’s attention before your start. Use the signal again during the activity – especially if the children are actively moving or enthusiastically excited – to regroup and calm the children down. Avoid using the "I"ll wait..." strategy because you'll just lose the interest of more children. Instead, actively quiet the children down and then proceed.  You might also need a quick relaxation exercise like pretending to breathe in a flower's smell and breathe out like blowing out a candle. Young children need help self-regulating and often find it hard to have the self-control to stop talking, moving, laughing, and so on.

  • Don’t rush around looking for things. Have all your materials ready, close to where you’ll use them. Think through everything you’ll need ahead of time, and make a list if you need to so you’re sure you are all set. Be organized! When I have student teachers videotape themselves, the most common reflection they make is that they needed to be better prepared and better organized.
  • Don’t let children’s responses sidetrack you. Children are notorious for answering a question with a lengthy response that can often be completely off-topic. Practice polite, kind ways of setting limits on children’s responses. You might say to a very young child, “I’d talk to you more about that during lunch, Robert. Let’s get back to the story.” For elementary-aged children, you might want to start teaching children how to monitor their responses to make sure they are talking about the topic of the question. Either way, it can be appropriate to stop a child from rambling. This can hard for those of us raised in cultures where cutting someone off can be considered rude. Get over your reluctance – the other children need you to set limits. 
  • Don’t rely only on handraising.  Expecting children to raise their hands to respond often leads to the same children speaking over and over again and others being passive and not interacting. Use alternatives to calling on children such as turn-and-talk, choral responses, or personal white boards. These strategies will also help if you have trouble with children’s long-winded responses. 
  • Don’t keep the children still for too long. Children need to move frequently. They will find it hard to focus and concentrate for long periods of time without some breaks to move, talk, sing, or loosen up a bit. Research shows that physical activity increases children’s focus and attention!
Try some of these new approaches and see if the children's engagement improves. Do you have other suggestions for managing your whole group activities better? Please share them in the comments!

15 comments:

  1. I had that problem when I first started my student teaching. After a week or two I learned not to talk over them and I also learned how to keep them engaged. For example, when we were doing reading on the rug I changed my voice. I tried to make it as exciting as possible.I also raised the tone of my voice. I stopped often to ask questions. I also did not rely on hand raising because it's always the same children raising their hands.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good point, Samerh, about the tone of voice. That's very important. We often joke about putting on the "teacher voice" but it's true! Having a commanding, yet warm tone, and enthusiasm really helps.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am sure I will be thoughtful of this advice once I begin some of my lessons for student teaching!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Lauren, stayed tuned! Once you begin teaching lessons, you'll have plenty more questions :-)

      Delete
  4. This is definitely very good advice and I wish I would have had it for my Junior Practicum when I was in a Pre-K 3 classroom. It is definitely the toughest with the little ones but after establishing rules and routines it gets much easier. Thanks for the great advice Dr. Rand!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jessika - I hope it helps in your future teaching!

      Delete
  5. I love my cooperating teacher! She does not use a quiet signal she just acknowledges the good behavior and the children instantly quiet down. She raises her tone of voice when they get too out of control but she does not yell at her students. She also allows the children to roam when needed and when its appropriate. We spoke and she explained that children NEED to move therefore in her classroom she allows them to transition to different parts of the classroom for certain activities. Even in 3rd grade children still need to move and should not be restricted to a desk.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Denise, I'm so glad you've found a good role model to learn from. It's so important to acknowledge good behavior - and to allow children movement in the classroom. It sounds like you're going to learn a great deal!

      Delete
  6. Dr. Rand,

    I never know what to say when a child wants to talk during meeting time about a topic the class is not discussing during that time. I like the idea you gave, which is to tell them "we can talk more about that during lunch." This is a good way of saying it without students feeling bad and think their words are not important. They will also most likely look forward for a conversation during lunch. :) I will try this technique in my class. Thanks again for the advice.


    Clara M.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I've observed a teacher give the children magic numbers in the beginning of the school year. They keep these magic numbers throughout the year, so when a group discussion is going on and it's time for the usual hand raising, the teacher instead calls a magic number to respond. This keeps the students on their toes and paying attention because they are listening for their number and have to think about a response if their number is called. I'm thinking about implementing this trick when I'm in a classroom of my own.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Heather - I love the "magic number" idea, especially how it draws on the natural interest children have in secret, magical things! Great way to keep their attention.

      Delete
  8. Dr. Rand,
    After your class, I agreed that the raising of hands can be quite boring. In considering that the child only listens when he/she is talking, I decided to try an alternative. This week, I incorporated the the turn-talk answering method. Initially the students looked a bit confused when I explained to them what I wanted them to do since they never seem to have done this before, but they quickly got the hang of it and really seemed to enjoy. I was also able to see everyone have an opportunity to speak. I do have to be cautious on the topic that we are discussing because in one circumstance the conversation was drifting. I did have to regroup, but overall it went well.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm so glad that the "turn and talk" method worked for you! My suggestion for keeping young children on topic is to keep the time for the talking very short - only a minute or two - and then move on. For young children, it can be difficult to have the self control to stay on topic for any length of time (this can be hard for adults too, ha ha!)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I believe especially for a younger classroom like a pre-school you must have a quick circle time meeting, and then move them around. Their attention span is short at that age. Even in a 2nd grade class you must make sure to have a quick transition afterwards. In our classroom we use the respect sign language to show that we are listening and being quiet. When I first saw this I loved this idea, because the classroom noise level was always low =]

    - Cecilia Huamani

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cecelia, Good point about attention spans. I think we over estimate children's attention span for sitting and listening to others at all grade levels. If we keep children actively engaged, though, we can extend that a great deal.

      Delete